Welcome to All American Pizza: A Taste of Tradition in Edmond, Oklahoma
Nestled in the heart of Edmond, Oklahoma, at 16726 N Pennsylvania Ave, All American Pizza stands as a cherished local institution dedicated to serving up authentic, high-quality pizza and classic American fare. More than just a place to eat, our restaurant embodies a commitment to community, quality ingredients, and the timeless joy of sharing a great meal. For years, we have been the go-to destination for families, friends, and neighbors seeking that perfect slice—a slice crafted with care, tradition, and a genuine passion for flavor. Our location in Edmond allows us to be deeply connected to the vibrant spirit of this city, making us a proud part of the local culinary landscape.
We understand that pizza is more than just dough, sauce, and cheese; it’s an experience. It’s the centerpiece of Friday night gatherings, the fuel for game days, and the comforting staple after a long week. At All American Pizza, we honor this tradition by focusing on consistency and excellence in every order. From our carefully sourced components to our time-tested preparation methods, every detail is managed to ensure that the pizza you receive meets the high standards our patrons have come to expect. We strive to create an atmosphere that is welcoming, relaxed, and conducive to making lasting memories over delicious food.
Our menu extends beyond our signature pizzas to include a variety of complementary dishes designed to satisfy every craving. Whether you are looking for a hearty side, a fresh salad, or one of our other classic American offerings, you will find options prepared with the same level of dedication to quality. We believe in providing substantial value alongside exceptional taste, ensuring that every visit leaves you feeling satisfied and already planning your next return.
Key Highlights of the All American Pizza Experience
What sets All American Pizza apart in the competitive world of casual dining? It is a combination of unwavering dedication to core values and a deep understanding of what our community desires in a neighborhood eatery. We focus on creating an environment where the food speaks for itself, supported by friendly service and a commitment to freshness.
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: We prioritize using fresh, high-quality components in all our preparations. This dedication starts with the foundation—our dough, made fresh daily—and extends to our sauces, cheeses, and toppings. This meticulous sourcing ensures a superior flavor profile that distinguishes our offerings from mass-produced alternatives.
A Menu Rooted in Comfort and Tradition: While our pizzas are the stars, our broader menu reflects beloved American comfort food staples. We aim to provide familiar, satisfying options that appeal to a wide range of tastes, making it easy for everyone in your party to find something they genuinely love, ensuring a hassle-free dining decision.
Community-Focused Atmosphere: Located centrally in Edmond, we strive to be more than just a transaction point. We cultivate a warm, inviting atmosphere where guests feel like part of the family. Our team is dedicated to providing attentive, genuine service that enhances the overall dining experience, whether you are dining in or picking up.
Versatility in Dining Options: Recognizing the varied needs of our patrons, we offer flexible ways to enjoy our food. Whether you prefer the convenience of takeout, the ease of delivery, or a relaxed sit-down meal at our Pennsylvania Avenue location, we are equipped to serve you efficiently and courteously, adapting to your schedule.
Crafting Your Perfect Meal in Edmond
At 16726 N Pennsylvania Ave, the team at All American Pizza is focused on one primary goal: delivering an exceptional meal experience every single time. We understand that in today's fast-paced environment, finding reliable, delicious food that feels both indulgent and familiar is important. Our continued success is built on the trust our Edmond patrons place in us—trust that we earn through consistent quality and dedicated service.
We invite you to stop by and discover why All American Pizza has become a staple in the local dining scene. Whether you are a long-time resident or just passing through Edmond, Oklahoma, we look forward to welcoming you to our table. Come taste the difference that tradition, quality ingredients, and a true passion for great pizza make. We are ready to serve you the best slice in town.
Amenities and More
Menus
Photos
Reviews All American Pizza
Jason Bointy
17-12-2025
Ordered the family deal. We only asked to add mushrooms to one of the pizzas, and were willing to pay extra , but the employee refused to add it to the pizza. Instead, he said " I can send you home with some mushrooms. We don't have an … More
LaTasha Morales
01-12-2025
Stopped by for a few pizzas. It was very crowded (day before Thanksgiving) so it took a bit longer than we were told, but the staff were very polite and looked like they were doing their best. Pizzas were good and overall, I would recommend All American, just know it may take a while when crowded. More
Shelly Elaine
06-08-2025
I've always raved about this place, but not tonight. It was supposed to be an hour and ended up being an hr and 15 min. The pizza has always been really good so not surprising the prices have gone up. However, the toppings were very skimpy … More
Kerry Graves
30-06-2025
I ordered 1 single topping pizza and cheese bread. For the second time in a row, I got RAW pizza and RAW breadsticks. Is there anyone at this location that cares? Where is the management ? This place runs like a zoo, these young people in there working do not care one bit. AVOID this location! More
Jody
25-05-2025
This was our first and last visit. We ordered a large all meat pizza.
They sure did skimp on the meat. Not to mention the sauce and cheese.
This pizza is horrible. Very disappointed. … More
Sean George
21-04-2025
This is how I got my pizza this evening. I know you all are busy, but making sure the pizza is at least properly placed in the box is common courtesy. Very disappointed as a consumer!
Jonathan Wetsel
18-04-2025
A delicious family-owned Oklahoma institution!
This is a fantastic pizza shop. … More
Internet Fabvl (InternetValty)
28-03-2025
Employees dont know to take orders right. One guy forgot the order ;---;. The other lady gave a girl free cinnamon sticks and not us even though we were eating for 45+ minutes. Need 2 better employees. God bless More
Tamiko Moore
12-01-2025
Wait was supposed to be 30 minutes turned into over an hour than the guy with blonde hair seems very unconcerned and barely wanted to help us and kept skipping over me it seemed they also made the pizza wrong and doing a lot of talking and … More
Sarah
09-01-2025
I won’t be returning after tonight’s disappointing experience. First, they got our order wrong (double ordered our pizzas). We arrived at the 20-minute mark (they said it would be ready in 15 minutes), but the order wasn’t finished. We … More
Jonathan Wetsel
25-12-2024
A delicious family-owned Oklahoma institution!
This is a fantastic pizza shop.
Their food is excellent and their staff are super kind!
They take care in picking their ingredients, and you can definitely taste the difference!
You can’t go wrong with one of their specialty configurations, but you can always build your own to get your pizza just the way you like it!
I’m already looking forward to my next visit! See you guys again soon!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Single-Topping Pizza
Recommendation for vegetarians
Highly recommend
Vegetarian offerings
Large vegetarian selection
Vegetarian options
You can customize your pizza or calzone with any veggies you like, and they even have a specialty veggie pizza that’s amazing!
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Reviews All American Pizza